Comparative Study of Fatty acids profile in some Mediterranean Virgin Olive Oils using Gas Chromatography

 

Rania Matar, Mayssam Salami, Zaid Al Assaf.

Department of Analytical and Food Chemistry, Faculty of Pharmacy, Damascus University,

Syrian Arab Republic.

*Corresponding Author E-mail: raniamatar1983@gmail.com

 

ABSTRACT:

Virgin olive oil represents the main fat source of the diet in the Mediterranean countries where the production of olive oil is concentrated. It has an important role in cardiovascular disease protection, because of its high bioactive components. The healthful effects are attributed to olive oil's high unsaturated fatty acids content which greatly varies in quantity according to the impact of geographic origin. This research aims to characterize local Syrian olive oils by determining their fatty acid composition, and compare the results with fatty acid composition in olive oil samples obtained from some exterior regions of the Mediterranean basin which are famous for olive cultivation. Twelve olive oil samples produced in four agricultural areas (coastal region, northern region, interior region, and southern region), available in local Syrian market were analyzed for its fatty acid composition by GC-MS, and the results were compared with fatty acid composition of six samples from several exterior regions ( Lebanon, Spain, and Greece). All the values of the fatty acid compositions are in compliance with the regulations of the International Olive Oil Council (IOC) and Codex Alimentarius. Among the evaluated oils the highest percentages of total saturated fatty acids were found in the Spanish samples and the southern Syrian oil samples that showed above of (18%) of saturated fatty acids, The highest percentage of MUFA and MUFA/PUFA index were found in the Greek oil sample up to(82%) and (29.09) respectively. Also, the results showed that the highest percentage of Linoleic acid (omega 6) was found in the southern Syrian oil samples up to (14%). In addition, the northern Syrian samples, in the same way the Greek oil samples showed the highest total unsaturated fatty acids percentages up to(85%), the highest Oleic acid percentages up to (80%), which makes them the most suitable for consumption.

 

KEYWORDS: Virgin Olive Oil, IOC, saturated fatty acids, unsaturated fatty acids, Oleic acid, GC-MS.

 

 


INTRODUCTION:

Olive cultivation is widespread throughout the Mediterranean region and is important for the rural economy, local heritage and the environment(1). Mediterranean areas have a significantly lower incidence of cardiovascular heart disease when compared with other countries according to some studies, This phenomenon has been associated with dietary habits that depend mainly on virgin Olive oil(2,3),

 

which is the most important food product that has a great effect due to its sensory properties and unique composition including antioxidants compounds such as phenols, tocopherols, and volatile compounds, in addition to the high level of unsaturated fatty acids especially Oleic acid and Linoleic acid, that have specific roles in the prevention of infection and degenerative diseases, neurological disorders, and breast and colon cancers.(4-7) Oleic acid is the main monounsaturated fatty acid in olive oil which it constitutes a large percentage of the total fatty acids in it(8), It has benefits health effects where it plays important role in decreasing blood level of low density lipoproteins (LDL) and increasing blood level of high density lipoproteins (HDL)(9), regulating the activity of signaling pathway of adrenergic receptors (α- and β-adrenoceptors) which are key elements in the central and peripheral control of blood pressure(8) thus, causing a reduction in blood pressure and prevention of heart disease.(8,10) Depending on studies, On November 2004, the Federal Drug Administration (FDA) of the U.S.A permitted a claim on olive oil labels concerning: “the benefits on the risk of coronary heart disease of eating about two tablespoons (23g) of olive oil daily, due to the monounsaturated fatty acid in olive oil”(11)in general, olive oil contents low level of saturated fatty acids (SFA): mainly Palmitic acid, Stearic acid, and trace of Myristic acid. It contents also High level of MUFA especially Oleic acid, and small amount of Palmitoleic acid, Low level of PUFA mainly Linoleic acid (Omega 6), very low Linolenic acid (Omega3) and Arachidonic acid(12). Fatty acids compositional limits adopted in the most recent editions of Codex Alimentarius and International Olive Oil Council (IOC) are given in table (1)(13)

 

Table (1) fatty acids composition in olive oil according Codex Alimentarius and IOC

Fatty acid

Codex Alimentarius

IOC

Myristic acid

C14:0

< 0.1

< 0.05

Palmitic acid

C16:0

7.5- 20

7.5- 20

Palmitoleic acid

C16:1

0.3-3.5

0.3-3.5

Heptadecanoic acid

C17:0

< 0.5

< 0.3

Heptadecenoic acid

C17:1

< 0.6

< 0.3

Stearic acid

C18:0

0.5- 5

0.5- 5

Oleic acid

C18:1 cis

55- 83

55- 83

Linoleic acid

C18:2

3.5-21

3.5-21

Linolenic acid

C18:3

--

< 1

Arachidonic acid

C20:4

< 0.8

< 0.6

 

The content of fatty acids as well as the ratio between unsaturated and saturated fatty acids is important parameter for determination of nutritional value of certain oil. Also, the determination of minor fatty acids in olive oil is very important for the acute knowledge of lipid profile during the authentication of the varietal origin of oils(14). therefore the newest trend in food processing industry in notifying the composition of olive oils and other food commodities for the content of each individual fatty acid.(15).

 

Fatty acids composition may differ from sample to sample, depending on the zone of production and the climate (temperature and rainfall) which may influence the physiological behavior of the olive tree and consequently the fruit ripening process modifying both the amount and the qualitative characteristics of oil in olives.(16) Some studies showed a relationship between thermal conditions and fatty acids composition of oil, where they found that locations with the high temperature and low altitude could be associated with an increased polyunsaturation and the lowest Oleic percentage. This could be attributed to a modification of lipid biosynthesis coinciding with a wet summer.(6) So many studies have been carried out to categorize virgin olive oils from different geographical regions(4,17). This research aims to evaluate the Syrian olive oil available in local market, produced in various Syrian agricultural areas by determining its content of fatty acids and some parameters (total saturated fatty acids SFA, total unsaturated fatty acids TUFA, monounsaturated fatty acids MUFA, polyunsaturated fatty acids PUFA, and MUFA/PUFA) that indicate its quality which compliance with Codex Alimentarius and IOC, and distinguish characteristics of the cultivar or the geographical origin of olive oil(18,19). and compare the results with fatty acid composition of olive oils produced in other Mediterranean regions (Lebanon, Spain, Greece). 

 

MATERIAL AND METHOD:

Chemicals, reagents and Instruments:

A 37- component Fatty acids methyl esters mix was purchased from Larodan Sweden, and was used to confirm the retention times and mass spectra for peak identification. (2mol/l) Methanolic potassium hydroxide solution, (1mol/l) hydrochloric acid solution, and n-Hexane were obtained from FLUKA. Gas chromatography (GC) Agilent A7890 equipped with a Mass spectroscopy (MS) was used for the specific analysis of Oleic acid in the oil extract.

 

Samples:

For the present study, Twelve olive oil samples produced in four agricultural areas included (coastal region, northern region, interior region, and southern region) were obtained from different local Syrian market, In addition to six olive oil samples (exterior regions) from other Mediterranean countries (Lebanon, Spain, and Greece.) were purchased for comparison.

The samples were labeled as indicated in table(2):

 

Table(2) olive oil samples obtained from Syrian local market and some Mediterranean areas:

Agricultural area

Sample 1

Sample2

Sample3

Syrian olive oil samples:

Coastal region

C1

C2

C3

 Northern region

N1

N2

N3

Interior region

I1

I2

I3

 Southern region

S1

S2

S3

Exterior olive oil samples

Spain

SP1

SP2

--

Greece

GR1

GR2

--

Lebanon

LE1

LE2

--

 

Identification and quantification of fatty acids methyl esters (FAMEs):

Esterification method:(20,21)

0.2g of olive oil was put into test tube and dissolved in 2.4ml of n-hexane, an aliquot 0.6 ml of (2mol/l) methanolic potassium hydroxide solution was added. The tube was capped and shaken for 20 s and allowed to boil for one minute in water bath at 70°C . Then, 1.2ml of (1mol/l) hydrochloric acid was added and gently stirred . Next , 3 ml of n-hexane was added and the upper phase containing the fatty acids methyl esters was decanted and dissolved in n-hexane to 10ml and 0.5 ϻl of the obtained solution was injected into the GC-MS.

 

Gas chromatography mass spectrometry analysis:(22)

GC–MS analysis was carried out using an Agilent A7890 gas chromatograph with a 5975C inert XL EL/CI MS detector equipped with HP-5MS 5% Phenyl Methyl Silox(30 m x 250 µm x 0.25 µm) capillary column . Helium was used as the carrier gas at a flow rate of 184.2 ml/ min with a split ratio of 30:1, and the sample size was1.0 μL. The following temperature program was used: injector temperature 230°C, initial column temperature 100°C (held 5 min), temperature ramp 10°C/min to 240°C and held at this temperature for 10min. The total run time was 30 min. the injection was performed manually. Data acquisition was realized in the scan mode (range 40-400 m/z). The fatty acids were identified by comparing their retention times and mass spectral data to the mass spectral data obtained by analysis of standard fatty acids methyl esters solution under the same conditions.

 

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION:

Fatty acids profile for olive oil samples:

the olive oil samples were determined by GC-MS, and the corresponding chromatograms were presented as: Coastal oil sample C1 figure(1), Northern oil sample N1 figure(2), Interior oil sample I1figure (3), Southern oil sample S1 figure (4), Lebanese oil sample LE1 figure(5), Spanish oil sample SP1 figure(6), Greek oil sample GR1 figure(7).

 

Determination of Saturated fatty acids:

the results showed that total SFA vary between (14-18.32%) where it was found in the highest value in Spanish oil samples whish contents Palmitic acid C16:0 in high value up to (16.98%), and low value of Stearic acid C18:0 (1.34%). While all Syrian samples contained lower amount of Palmitic acid and higher amount of Stearic acid ranged between (11.88- 15.16%) and (2.19-2.96%) respectively. the other exterior samples content between (13.4-14.07%) Palmitic acid, and (1.63- 2.44%) Stearic acid. There was no trace of Myristic acid C14:0 in any of the sample tested which consistent with Codex Alimentarius, as shown in the table (3). all these SFA percentages were consistent with those obtained in most studies on Mediterranean olive oil samples(6,23).

 

Determination of unsaturated fatty acids:

the results showed that total unsaturated fatty acids vary between (80.51-85.28%), the Greek oil samples contained the highest percentage of MUFA (82.04%) while all other samples were contained MUFA ranging between (67.73- 77.05%), Oleic acid forms the majority of them in all oil samples, Palmitioleic acid forms small amount of them in all oil samples except the coast and northern oil samples that were free of it due to the lower temperatures in these areas (between 25-35°C) than the rest of Syria, while the highest percentage of PUFA was found in southern oil sample where it reached (13.95%) which contains Linoleic acid only, and no Linolenic acid which consistent with Codex Alimentarius. the high MUFA/PUFA ratio was in the Greek oil sample (29.09) which makes it the most stable oil, followed by Spanish oil sample (17.9),) while the Syrian oil samples ranged between(4.85-8.60) similary to studies have shown the MUFA/PUFA ratio in Syrian olive oil is up to (48)(6). the unsaturated fatty acids profile are listed in table (4)

 

The differences observed between olive oil samples for the fatty acid composition may be explained by the different agricultural areas. This agree with the results described by other authors for oils from olives growing in different regions(17-24-25).  Notes that the fatty acids composition of all olive oil samples was in the range of Codex Alimentarius and IOC standard. These results contradict some studies in Egypt, which have worked to compare commercial olive oils exported from some Mediterranean areas (Syria, Spain, and Greece). and available in Egyptian markets, which showed that Spanish oil contained the highest percentage of Oleic acid up to 78%, while Syrian olive oils did not contain more than 65% and no trans acids was found in all samples(6) . And also these results agree with the results of a study carried out by the general commission for agricultural research in Syria GCSAR 2006 which showed the high quality of olive oil in various cultivated Syrian areas.(26).

 

Table (3): saturated fatty acids composition of different types of virgin olive oil

Olive oil brand

SFA

C16:0

C18:0

C14:0

Coastal region

C1

14.07

11.88

2.19

---

C2

13.92

11.52

2.4

---

C3

14.01

11.26

2.75

---

Northern region

N1

16.7

14.19

2.51

---

N2

16.25

14.05

2.2

---

N3

16.64

14.14

2.5

---

Interior region

I1

16.46

13.5

2.96

---

I2

16.55

13.9

2.65

---

I3

16.49

13.8

2.69

---

Southern region

S1

18

15.16

2.84

---

S2

18.2

15.2

3

---

S3

17.98

15.01

2.97

---

Spain

SP1

18.32

16.98

1.34

---

SP2

18.21

16.81

1.4

---

Greece

GR1

15.11

13.48

1.63

---

GR2

15.01

13.4

1.61

---

Lebanon

LE1

16.51

14.01

2.44

---

LE2

16.8

14.2

2.6

---

 

Table (4): unsaturated fatty acids composition of different types of virgin olive oil

Olive oil brand

C16:1

C18:1

C18:2

C18:3

TUFA

MUFA

PUFA

MUFA/PUFA

Coastal region

C1

---

75.28

9.71

---

85.28

75.57

9.71

7.78

C2

---

74.45

10.2

---

84.9

74.7

10.2

7.32

C3

---

74.3

9.95

---

84.53

74.58

9.95

7.49

Northern region

N1

---

71.53

10.15

---

83.28

72.35

10.15

7.12

N2

---

70.11

10.2

---

81.06

70.86

10.2

6.94

N3

---

70.1

10.24

---

81.14

70.9

10.24

6.92

Interior region

I1

0.41

73.65

8.82

---

84.08

75.26

8.82

8.53

I2

0.39

73.51

8.7

---

83.6

74.9

8.7

8.60

I3

0.34

73.71

8.79

---

84.05

75.26

8.79

8.56

Southern region

S1

0.28

66.73

13.8

---

81.95

68.15

13.8

4.93

S2

0.31

66.22

13.95

---

81.68

67.73

13.95

4.85

S3

0.3

67.95

13.85

---

83.2

69.35

13.85

5

Spain

SP1

0.78

74.63

4.6

---

81.65

77.05

4.6

16.75

SP2

0.75

73.99

4.25

---

80.51

76.26

4.25

17.9

Greece

GR1

0.29

80.8

2.82

---

84.86

82.04

2.82

29.09

GR2

0.29

80.0

2.9

---

83.29

80.39

2.9

27.72

Lebanon

LE1

0.26

70.96

8.35

---

81.27

72.92

8.35

8.7

LE2

0.28

70.66

8.21

---

80.9

72.69

8.21

8.85

 


CONCLUSIONS:

The fatty acids profile, which is influenced by cultivar and environment, is an important part of the oil quality, it has previously been used by a number of authors as a parameter for oil classification(28-27), where the proportion of the different fatty acids can determine the nutritional value of the oil. the fatty acids profiles of all olive oil samples were in the range of Codex Alimentarius and IOC standard.

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS:

The authors acknowledge the financial support received from Damascus University. Scientific assistance provided by Prof. Mounir Ataei (Faculty of Pharmacy, Arab international university) , D. Ghassan Abochama (Faculty of science, University of Damascus) and D. Wissam Zam ( Al Andalus university) is greatly appreciated.

 

 

Figure (1) Chromatogram of C1 olive oil sample

 

Figure (2) Chromatogram of N1 olive oil sample

 

 

Figure (3) Chromatogram of I1 olive oil sample

 

Figure (4) Chromatogram of S1 olive oil sample

 

 

Figure (5) Chromatogram of L1 olive oil sample

 

 

Figure (6) Chromatogram of SP1 olive oil sample

 

Figure (7) Chromatogram of GC1 olive oil sample

 

REFERENCES:

1.      DGPA/ONH. L'oleiculture tunisienne, Olivae. 1996; 61, 12-20.

2.      Martínez-González M.A , Sa´nchez-Villegas A. The Emerging Role of Mediterranean Diets in Cardiovascular Epidemiology: Monounsaturated Fats, Olive Oil, Red Wine, or The Whole Pattern?. Eur J Epidemiol. 2004; 19, 9–13.

3.      Menotti A et al. Twenty-Five-Year Mortality From Coronary Heart Disease and Its Prediction in Five Cohorts of Middle-Aged Men in Finland, The Netherlands, and Italy. Prev Med. 1990;19, 270–278.

4.      Mansour A et al. Effect of Agricultural Sites on Differentiation Between Chemlali and Neb Jjmel Olive Oils. J.Oleo Sci . 2015; 64,(4) 381-392.

5.      Angerosa F et al. Volatile Compounds in Virgin Olive Oil: Occurrence and their Relationship with the Quality. J Chromatogr A. 2004; 1054, 17-31.

6.      Bhnsawy R, Hassanen N, Eid M. Comparative study of the quality of extra virgin olive oil in the Egyptian market (from different Mediterranean countries). Curr. Sci. Int. 2017; 6(1),208-217.

7.      Tsimidou M, Blekas G, Boskou D. Olive oil. In Caballero B,Trugo L, Finglas P (Eds.). Encyclopedia of food science, food technology and nutrition London, Academic Press. 2003; 4252-4260.

8.      Teres S. et al. Oleic Acid Content is Responsible For the Reduction in Blood Pressure Induced by Olive Oil. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008; 16,105(37), 13811-13816.

9.      Godswill N et al. effect of dietary fatty acids on human health: focus on palm oil from Elaeis guineensis Jacq. and Useful Recommendations. Food and public health. 2016; 6(3), 75-85.

10.    Kris-Etherton P M et al. High-Monounsaturated Fatty Acid Diets Lower Both Plasma Cholesterol and Triacylglycerol Concentrations. Am J Clin Nutr. 1999; 70, 1009–15.

11.     Covas M I. Olive oil and the cardiovascular system. Pharmacological research. 2007; 55, 175-186.

12.    Pfeuffer M, Jahreis G. Trans fatty acids. Origin, metabolism, health risks. Ernahrungs Umschau. 2018; 65(12): 196-203.

13.    International Olive Oil Coucil . Trade standards applying to olive oil and olive pomace oil. COI/T.15/NC, no 3/Rev.1./5.December 2003. International Olive Oil Council, Madrid, Spain.

14.    Ollivier D, et al. Triacylglycerol and fatty acid composition of French virgin olive oils, characterization by chemometrics. J. Agric. Food Chem. 2003; 51: 5723-5731.

15.    Vesna K . Shaban M, Biljana B. Fatty acid composition of edible oils and fats. Journal of Hygienic Engineering and Design. 2013; 4:112-116.

16.    Montedoro G F et al. Le Caratteristiche Del Prodotto e Le Relazioni Con Le Variabili Agronomiche, In: P. Fiorino (ed.), Olea - Trattato di olivicoltura. Edagricole, Bologna (Italy). 2003; 263-289.

17.    Ouni Y et al. Characterization and Quantification of Phenolic Compounds of Extra Virgion Olive Oils According to Their Geographical Origin By a Rapid and Resolutive LC-ESI-TOF MS method. Food Chem. 2011; 127, 1263-1267.

18.    Giuffre A M. Alcoli alifatici e terpenici in olio di olive estratto da cultivar alleviate in Calabria. Industrie Alimentari. 2013; 52: 28-35.

19.    Giuffre A M. Steroli, Eritrodiolo e uvaolo in olio di olive da cultivar cultivate in Calabria. Industrie Alimentari. 2012; 51: 20-26.

20.    Snežana K et al. Determination of Trans Fatty Acids in Foodstuffs by Gas Chromatography–mass Spectrometry after Simultaneous Microwave-Assisted Extraction–Esterification. J. Serb. Chem. Soc. 2010; 75 (6), 803–812.

21.    Vishwe P S et al. Comparative Study of Biodiesel Production From Pure Sunflower Oil and Waste Sunflower Oil. Research J. Pharma. Dosage forms and tech. 2013; 5(3), 171-173.

22.    Yogeshwar R M et al. A Sensitive and Selective GC-MS Method for The Determination of Process Related Genotoxic Impurities in Esomeprazole Magnesium. Asian J. Research Chem. 2010; 3(2) ,395-397.

23.    Tanilgan K, Ozcan M M, Unver A. Physical and chemical characteristics of five Turkish olive varieties and their oils. Grasas Y Aceities. 2007; 58(2): 142-147.

24.    Gargouri B, et al. Effect of growing region on quality characteristics and phenolic compounds of chemlali extra virgin olive oils. Acta Physiol. Plant. 2013; 35: 2801-2812.

25.    Issaoui M, et al. Effect of the growing area conditions on differentiation between chemlali and chetoui olive oils. Food Chem. 2010; 119: 220-225.

26.    Di Terlizzi B et al. Syrian national strategic plan for olive oil quality: final report. Bari, CIHEAM. 2007; 17-34.

27.    Haddada F M, et al. Analytical evaluation of six monovarietal virgin olive oils from Northern Tunisia. Eur. J. Lipid Sci.Technol. 2008;110: 905-913.

28.    Rondanini D P, et al. Fatty acid profiles of varietal virgin olive oils from mature orchards in warm arid valleys of Northwestern Argentina. Grasas Aceites. 2011; 62: 399-409.

 

 

Received on 22.10.2019          Modified on 02.12.2019

Accepted on 24.01.2020         © RJPT All right reserved

Research J. Pharm. and Tech 2020; 13(5): 2345-2349.

DOI: 10.5958/0974-360X.2020.00422.9